Common Mistakes NRIs Make While Filing India Taxes

Filing taxes can be a complex process, especially for Non-Resident Indians (NRIs). NRIs living abroad often face unique challenges when it comes to understanding and complying with India's tax regulations. In this article, we will discuss some common mistakes that NRIs make while filing taxes in India and provide insights on how to avoid them. Whether you are an NRI or someone interested in learning about this topic, this article will help you gain a better understanding of the potential pitfalls and provide guidance for a smoother tax filing experience.

As an NRI, it is crucial to understand your residential status for taxation purposes. The Indian tax system differentiates between resident and non-resident individuals based on the number of days they stay in India during a financial year. NRIs need to be aware of the specific criteria and rules that determine their tax residency status.

Ignoring Tax Residency Rules

One common mistake NRIs make is failing to correctly determine their tax residency status. This mistake can have significant implications on their tax liability. NRIs should carefully assess the number of days spent in India and ensure compliance with the tax residency rules to avoid any penalties or unnecessary tax burdens.

NRIs can check their tax residency status by considering the following factors:

Physical Presence: The number of days an individual spends in India during a financial year is a significant factor in determining tax residency. The income tax laws in India classify individuals into three categories based on their physical presence: resident, non-resident, and resident but not ordinary resident (RNOR). NRIs must assess their physical presence in India to determine their tax residency status.
Residential Status: The residential status of an individual is determined by the number of days spent in India during the previous financial year and the preceding years. The specific criteria vary depending on various factors, including citizenship, employment, and intention to stay in India. NRIs should evaluate their residential status based on these criteria.
Employment and Business Activities: NRIs engaged in employment or business activities in India need to consider the impact on their tax residency status. The nature and duration of employment or business activities can influence the determination of tax residency.
Tie Breaker Rules: In cases where an individual qualifies as a resident in more than one country, tax treaties often incorporate tie breaker rules. These rules consider factors such as permanent home, center of vital interests, habitual abode, and nationality to determine tax residency. NRIs should examine the tie-breaker rules to ascertain their tax residency status.

You can also check the same here on Inri.

Failing to Claim Tax Benefits

NRIs are entitled to various tax benefits and exemptions provided by the Indian government. However, many NRIs overlook these benefits or are unaware of their eligibility. By failing to claim these tax benefits, NRIs may end up paying more taxes than necessary. It is essential to stay informed about the available deductions and exemptions to optimize tax savings.

NRIs have the opportunity to benefit from exemptions under specific sections of the Indian Income Tax Act when it comes to long-term capital gains. Sections 54, 54EC, and 54F offer avenues for claiming exemptions on capital gains and seeking refunds for any TDS (Tax Deducted at Source) deducted.

Section 54 allows for an exemption on long-term capital gains resulting from the sale of a house property. On the other hand, Section 54F provides an exemption for the sale of any asset other than a house property.

By leveraging these provisions, NRIs can potentially reduce their tax liability on capital gains and claim refunds for any TDS deducted. These exemptions offer significant opportunities for NRIs to optimize their tax position and retain a larger portion of their capital gains when filing their tax returns.

For instance, consider an NRI who sells a house property and realizes a long-term capital gain of INR 60 lakhs. Under Section 54, if the NRI invests the capital gain amount or a part of it in another residential property within the specified time frame, they can claim an exemption on the capital gains. This means that the NRI will not be liable to pay tax on the amount invested, resulting in significant tax savings.

Furthermore, if the NRI sells an asset other than a house property and earns long-term capital gains, it can utilize Section 54F. This section allows for an exemption on capital gains if the proceeds are reinvested in a residential property within the stipulated period. By taking advantage of this provision, the NRI can potentially reduce their tax liability and retain a larger portion of their capital gains.

In both cases, it's crucial for the NRI to comply with the conditions mentioned in the respective sections and fulfil the necessary documentation requirements. By doing so, they can claim the exemptions while filing their tax return and seek a refund of any TDS deducted from the capital gains.

Additional deductions for expenses like education, healthcare, and housing loans are examples of commonly missed opportunities. NRIs should familiarize themselves with the available exemptions and deductions and utilize them effectively to minimize their tax liability.

Failing to comply with Tax processes

Overlooking Double Taxation Avoidance Agreements (DTAA)

Double Taxation Avoidance Agreements (DTAA) are bilateral agreements signed between India and other countries to prevent double taxation for NRIs. Ignoring the provisions of DTAA can result in NRIs paying taxes both in India and their country of residence. NRIs must understand and leverage the benefits provided by DTAA to avoid double taxation and reduce their tax liability.

Incorrect Classification of Income

Proper classification of income is critical for accurate tax filing. NRIs often struggle with classifying their income correctly, especially when it comes to differentiating between taxable and non-taxable income. Errors in income classification can lead to incorrect tax calculations and potential legal issues. It is advisable to seek professional advice or refer to relevant tax guidelines to ensure accurate income classification.

Not Maintaining Proper Documentation

Maintaining comprehensive documentation is essential for NRIs during tax filing. Failure to keep records of income, expenses, investments, and other financial transactions can create challenges during the filing process. NRIs should maintain organized and accurate documentation to support their claims and substantiate any deductions or exemptions.

Neglecting to File Tax Returns

NRIs sometimes assume that if they do not have any taxable income in India, they do not need to file tax returns. However, even if there is no taxable income, NRIs may still be required to file tax returns under certain circumstances, such as holding assets or financial interests in India. Failing to file tax returns when necessary can lead to penalties and legal complications.

Neglecting Tax Planning

Proper tax planning is crucial for NRIs to optimize their tax liability. Many NRIs fail to engage in tax planning activities, resulting in missed opportunities for tax savings. By strategically planning their investments, utilizing tax-efficient instruments, and staying updated with tax law changes, NRIs can minimize their tax burden and maximize their financial returns.

Not Utilizing Electronic Filing

In today's digital age, electronic filing has made the tax filing process more convenient and efficient. However, some NRIs still prefer traditional paper filing methods or overlook the option of electronic filing. Electronic filing not only saves time but also reduces the chances of errors. NRIs should embrace electronic filing methods for a smoother and more streamlined tax filing experience.

Ignoring Tax Deadlines

Missing tax deadlines can lead to penalties and interest charges. NRIs often overlook or forget tax filing deadlines, especially when residing abroad. Staying informed about the relevant tax deadlines is crucial to avoid unnecessary penalties and ensure timely compliance with tax obligations. The tax deadline for 2023 is July 31, 2023, Monday.

Failure to Comply with Foreign Asset Reporting

NRIs with assets or financial interests outside India are required to comply with foreign asset reporting requirements. Failing to disclose foreign assets or providing incorrect information can result in penalties and legal consequences. NRIs should familiarize themselves with the reporting obligations and fulfils them accurately and promptly.

Reporting Requirements: NRIs are required to disclose the following details of their foreign assets and income in their income tax returns:

Details of foreign bank accounts, including any interest earned. Ownership or investment in foreign entities such as companies, partnerships, trusts, etc.
Details of immovable properties owned abroad, such as land, buildings, etc.
Any financial interest in foreign entities, including shares, debentures, bonds, mutual funds, etc.
Any other assets or income earned outside India.

Forms for reporting: NRIs are required to use the appropriate forms to report their foreign assets and income. The specific forms depend on the nature of the assets and income. The commonly used forms include:

Form ITR-2: For reporting income from foreign assets and foreign income sources. Form FA: For details of foreign assets if the total income exceeds INR 50 lakhs.

Penalties for non-compliance: Failure to comply with foreign asset reporting requirements can lead to penalties and consequences under the Income Tax Act. Penalties can range from monetary fines to prosecution for tax evasion.

Not Seeking Professional Assistance

Navigating the intricacies of Indian tax laws can be challenging, especially for NRIs. Many NRIs attempt to file taxes independently without seeking professional assistance. However, given the complexities involved, it is advisable for NRIs to consult tax experts or professionals who specialize in NRI taxation. Professional guidance can help NRIs understand their tax obligations, maximize tax benefits, and ensure accurate and compliant tax filings.

We are also thrilled to announce an upcoming seminar illuminating the complex and confusing world of Indian taxation liabilities for NRIs. This exclusive event will feature esteemed tax expert CA Jaydeep Sanghani, who will provide invaluable insights and guidance on navigating the intricacies of Indian tax laws and the tax filing processes. Join us here for an in-depth exploration of the key aspects of Indian taxation that NRIs must know.

Filing taxes as an NRI requires a comprehensive understanding of India's tax laws and regulations. By avoiding common mistakes such as ignoring tax residency rules, failing to report global income, and overlooking tax benefits and exemptions, NRIs can ensure a smooth and hassle-free tax filing experience. Staying informed, seeking professional assistance when needed, and proactively planning for taxes can help NRIs optimize their tax liability and stay compliant with the tax laws of India.

To avoid common pitfalls, it’s crucial to stay informed about the best investments, such as those detailed in our article on the Top Small-cap Mutual Funds For NRIs In 2024. Read more here.

For a complete walkthrough on how to file your taxes properly, check out the NRI's Ultimate Guide to India Tax Filing.