Which election should you choose in PFIC?

Investing in mutual funds is a popular way for Indian investors residing in the United States to grow their wealth and participate in the Indian financial market. However, it's important to be aware of certain tax obligations and regulations that apply to these investments. One requirement is understanding the Passive Foreign Investment Company ( PFIC) rules.

The Passive Foreign Investment Company (PFIC) rules have important implications for U.S. taxpayers' investments in foreign companies. PFIC investments can result in complex tax reporting and potentially higher tax liabilities.

‍

What is PFIC?

A Passive Foreign Investment Company (PFIC) is a foreign corporation that primarily generates passive income, such as interest, dividends, or capital gains. PFICs can include certain types of foreign mutual funds, making it crucial for Indian investors in the US to understand their implications. Read More Here

‍

What is its Applicability?

The PFIC rules apply to Indian mutual fund investments in the US that meet the criteria of a passive foreign investment company. Generally, if the mutual fund does not qualify for the " Deferred tax, Qualified Electing Fund" (QEF) or " Mark-to-Market" ( MTM) election, it will be treated as a PFIC. It's important to note that most Indian mutual funds are considered PFICs; so if you have investments in Indian mutual funds, you’d need to report them via PFIC. Know more here.

To navigate these rules effectively, taxpayers can make PFIC elections. In this article, we will explore the two main PFIC elections - the Qualified Electing Fund (QEF) election and the Mark-to-Market (MTM) election - and discuss factors to consider when choosing the most suitable election for your specific situation.

‍

Deferred Tax

Deferred tax refers to the tax liability that arises from the temporary differences between the financial reporting of a PFIC and its tax reporting. These temporary differences can occur due to variations in recognising and measuring assets, liabilities, revenues, and expenses.

Deferred tax liabilities arise when the financial statements of a PFIC reflect higher income or gains than the taxable income reported for tax purposes. This can happen because certain revenues or gains may be recognized for accounting purposes before they are recognized for tax purposes. The deferred tax liability represents the additional tax that will be payable in future periods when the temporary differences reverse.

On the other hand, deferred tax assets may arise when the financial statements of a PFIC reflect lower income or losses than the taxable income reported for tax purposes. This can occur when expenses or losses are recognized for accounting purposes before they are recognized for tax purposes. The deferred tax asset represents the potential tax benefit that can be realized in future periods when the temporary differences reverse.

‍

Qualified Electing Fund (QEF) Election

The Qualified Electing Fund (QEF) election is available to taxpayers who invest in Passive Foreign Investment Companies (PFICs). By making a QEF election, taxpayers can choose a more favourable tax treatment for their PFIC investments than the default rules.

Under the QEF election, taxpayers treat their share of a PFIC's ordinary earnings and net capital gains as taxable income. This means that the income generated by the PFIC is included in the taxpayer's annual tax return, similar to reporting income from a U.S. mutual fund. By doing so, the taxpayer avoids the complex calculations and tax deferral issues associated with the default PFIC rules.

To make a QEF election, certain requirements must be met. The taxpayer needs to obtain timely and accurate information from the PFIC about its income and assets. This information is necessary to accurately report the taxpayer's share of the PFIC's income on an annual basis. Additionally, the taxpayer must provide an annual statement to the IRS, disclosing their share of the PFIC's income.

While the QEF election simplifies the taxation of PFIC investments, it may still involve additional reporting obligations. Taxpayers must stay updated on the PFIC's financial information and ensure compliance with the reporting requirements associated with the QEF election. It is important to note that the availability of the QEF election depends on the PFIC providing the necessary information to the taxpayer.

Before making a QEF election, taxpayers should carefully evaluate their specific circumstances and consult with a tax professional. By doing so, they can assess the benefits and implications of the QEF election and determine if it is the most suitable option for their PFIC investments.

‍

Mark-to-Market (MTM) Election

The Mark-to-Market (MTM) election is another option available to taxpayers with investments in Passive Foreign Investment Companies (PFICs). By making an MTM election, taxpayers can simplify the taxation and reporting of their PFIC investments.

Under the MTM election, taxpayers mark their PFIC investments to market at the end of each year. This means that the value of the PFIC is adjusted to its fair market value, and any increase or decrease in value is recognized as ordinary income or loss for the year. This eliminates the need for complex calculations and reporting of PFIC income under the default rules.

To make an MTM election, certain requirements must be met. The election is available only for marketable securities, such as publicly traded stocks, bonds and mutual funds. Other types of PFIC investments, such as interests in non-publicly traded companies, do not qualify for the MTM election. Additionally, taxpayers must attach a statement to their tax return, reporting the marked-to-market gains or losses from their PFIC investments.

The MTM election offers simplicity and ease of reporting for PFIC investments. By recognizing the changes in the value of the PFIC investments as ordinary income or loss, taxpayers can avoid the complexities associated with the default PFIC rules. This allows for a more streamlined tax reporting process.

It is important to note that the availability of the MTM election depends on the specific requirements outlined by the tax authorities. Taxpayers should consult with a tax professional to determine if they qualify for the MTM election and to ensure proper compliance with the reporting obligations.

Taxpayers can eliminate complex calculations and reporting requirements by marking the PFIC investments to market at the end of each year. However, it is crucial to meet the eligibility criteria and fulfil the reporting obligations associated with the MTM election.

‍

Summary of differences between Deferred Tax and MTM

Issue Section 1291Section 1296How to Elect?• Default Election, no requirement for specific election• Can be elected by filing Form 8621• Can switch from Default Election in any year by paying deferred tax Gain on Sale• Sale (-) Basis • Gain is taxed as deferred Gain• Sale (-) Lower of Last year FMV/Basis• Gain is Ordinary Income Loss on Sale• Losses on Sale are allowed as Capital Loss under normal provisions• Losses are Ordinary Losses upto prior taxed ordinary income• Losses in excess of the prior taxed ordinary income are allowed as Capital Losses under normal provisions Gain / Loss on Holding• No Gain / Loss during holding period• Taxes are payable even during holding period for MTM Gains Tax on Dividends Taxed as Excess Distributions at highest tax bracket (+) Interest If not excess distributions, taxed as NON-QUALIFIED Dividends Taxed as NON-QUALIFIED Dividends Tax Credits Not available on Sale Available for Dividends against Tax Liability (Not Interest)Not available on Sale Available for Dividends under Normal Provisions Tax Rates Highest Tax Bracket for Gain on Sale or for excess distributions Additional Interest Payable As per Taxpayer’s Tax Bracket as Income is ordinary income

‍

Factors to Consider in Choosing an Election

When deciding which PFIC election to choose, several factors should be considered:

• Investment goals and strategy: Evaluate whether the QEF or MTM election aligns better with your investment objectives and long-term strategy.
• Holding period and anticipated gains: Assess the expected holding period for your PFIC investments and anticipate the potential gains or losses. This analysis can help determine which election is more suitable.
• Reporting complexity and costs: Consider each election's additional reporting obligations and associated costs. Determine if you have the resources and expertise to fulfil the requirements.

In conclusion, choosing the right PFIC election requires careful consideration of your specific circumstances and goals. It is advisable to consult with a tax professional who can provide guidance tailored to your situation.

Inri helps in online reporting of PFIC and consultations with CPAs expert in foreign investments.