NRE FDs vs Debt Mutual Funds

Fixed deposits (FD) and debt mutual funds are two popular investment options that are suitable for risk-averse investors. Both of them offer attractive returns and liquidity. But which one is better for NRIs? In this article, we will compare Non-Resident External (NRE) FD and Debt Mutual Funds on various parameters and help you decide which one suits your needs and goals better.

‍

What is Non-Resident External (NRE) FD?

NRE FD is a type of bank deposit that allows you to park your foreign currency earnings in India in INR and earn interest on them. The interest earned on NRE FD is tax-free in India and can be repatriated (transferred) to a foreign country without any restrictions.

The minimum tenure of NRE FD is one year, and the maximum is 10 years. The interest rates on NRE FD vary from bank to bank and depend on the tenure and amount of deposit. NRE FDs may offer interest as high as 8% (tax-free in India)!

‍

What is a Debt Mutual Fund?

A debt mutual fund is a type of mutual fund that invests in fixed-income securities such as government bonds, corporate bonds, treasury bills, commercial papers, etc. These funds aim to offer regular income and the potential for capital appreciation.

The returns on debt funds depend on the interest rates, credit quality, and maturity of the underlying securities. They are subject to market risk, credit risk, and interest rate risk.

‍

Key Differences Between NRE FD and Debt Mutual Fund

The following table summarises the key differences between NRE FD and Debt Mutual Fund on various parameters:

‍

Debt Mutual Fund Information

Aspect	NRE FD	Debt Mutual Fund
Return Potential	Fixed and guaranteed	Fixed, but not guaranteed (can change based on market conditions)
Investment	Lumpsum	Lump Sum or Systematic Investment Plan (SIP)
Interest/ Return	4.5% to 8%	8% to 10%
Risk	Low	Low to moderate
Tenure	1 year to 10 years	No minimum investment tenure
Lock in Period	Duration of the fixed deposit	No lock-in period
Investment Horizon	Short to long-term	Short to medium-term
Minimum Investment	Rs 1,000 to Rs 20,000, varies from bank to bank	Rs 500
Liquidity	Premature withdrawal is allowed with a penalty	Redemption is allowed anytime without penalty
Diversification	Limited - investment in a single fixed deposit	Diversified portfolio of debt securities
Taxation	Interest is tax-free in India	Capital gains are taxed as per your income tax slab rate.
Expense	No additional charges	The asset management company charges fund management fees as the expense ratio.
Repatriation	Principal and interest can be repatriated freely	Principal and gains can be repatriated after paying the tax
Currency	Foreign currency earnings in INR	Indian rupees
Deposit Insurance and Credit Guarantee Corporation (DICGC)	Capital + interest worth Rs 5 lakhs is insured under DICGC.	No insurance available
Loan	You can avail loan against your FD	You can avail a loan upto 80% of the investment value.
Inflation Protection	Limited	Potential to beat inflation over the long term
Regulatory Body	Regulated by Reserve Bank of India (RBI)	Regulated by the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI)

‍

What Should NRIs Choose: NRE FD or Debt Mutual Fund?

The choice between NRE FD and Debt Mutual Fund depends on your risk appetite, return expectation, and investment horizon. Here are some general guidelines to help you decide:

‍

Scenarios Where NRE FD Works Better

NRE FD works better in the following scenarios:

You have a low-risk tolerance and prefer a fixed and assured income.

You have a short to long-term investment horizon (1 to 10 years).

You want to avoid the hassle of filing tax returns in India and paying tax on your income.

You want to transfer your money back to your foreign country without any restrictions or delays.

‍

Scenarios Where Debt Mutual Funds Work Better

Debt Mutual Funds work better in the following scenarios:

You have a low to moderate-risk appetite and seek a higher return potential.

You have a short to medium-term investment horizon (up to 5 years).

You are comfortable with the market fluctuations and credit quality of the underlying securities.

Debt mutual funds are tax efficient, as the capital gains are taxed only on redemption.

‍

Conclusion

NRE FD and Debt Mutual Funds are both viable investment options for NRIs, but they have different features, benefits, and drawbacks. If your intention is to invest in liquid funds as a means to cover emergency expenses, then that's a suitable choice.

However, if your goal involves investing in debt funds for the purpose of asset allocation or to potentially achieve better returns than FDs, it's crucial to be aware of a significant factor - for NRIs, taxes are deducted at the source from capital gains.

Thus, choose the one that matches your risk profile, return expectation, investment duration, and tax situation. You should also diversify your portfolio across different asset classes and instruments to optimise your returns and reduce your risk.

You may also consult with a financial advisor who can provide personalised guidance based on individual circumstances. Happy Investing!

It's important to note, when diversifying your investment portfolio, it's crucial to understand different asset types, such as debt mutual funds and FDs. To avoid common diversification mistakes, read our blog here.

Many NRIs unknowingly make mistakes in choosing between FDs and mutual funds, which can significantly impact long-term returns. Read more on Mistake NRIs does while investing in India on our detailed blog.

‍